• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
ICYMI: Vegetable prices reaching new heights

Better food price controls needed to shield poor

24th August 2020
Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

2nd December 2023
Bureau Veritas has taken a bold step toward undertaking a solar and back-up project that allows it to sustain its business continuity for its Cape Town AgriFood Laboratory. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Bureau Veritas goes solar at Cape Town agrifood lab

2nd December 2023
Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

1st December 2023

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

1st December 2023
Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

1st December 2023
Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

1st December 2023
ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

1st December 2023
Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

1st December 2023
In pictures: Safeguarding indigenous plants for the future

In pictures: Safeguarding indigenous plants for the future

30th November 2023
Food for Mzansi gives voiceless farmers a much-needed voice

Food For Mzansi gives voiceless farmers a much-needed voice

30th November 2023
The Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity Group unveils the November 2023 Household Affordability Index, exposing surging expenses and stagnant wages affecting South African households. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Economic squeeze: Families struggle as costs soar

30th November 2023

Faces of Summer: Celebrate the rich history of Thokozani Wines

30th November 2023
Saturday, December 2, 2023
15 GLOBAL MEDIA AWARDS
Login
Food For Mzansi
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
Food For Mzansi
Home Food for Thought Between the Headlines

Better food price controls needed to shield poor

by The Conversation
24th August 2020
in Between the Headlines
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
ICYMI: Vegetable prices reaching new heights

According to the latest consumer price index report released by Stats SA, the month of March 2023 saw an annual consumer price inflation increase to 7.1% from 7.0% in February 2023. In March 2023, the consumer price index rose by 1% monthly. Photo: Envato

Covid-19 has wrought havoc on poor households in countries across the world. In South Africa, more and more people are facing hunger resulting from mass job losses and small, poorly implemented supplementary cash grants. Ihsaan Bassier, Refiloe Joala and Dr Thando Vilakazi report for The Conversation.

On top of this, the pandemic has put in stark relief the country’s poorly understood food system, in which powerful firms operate with little oversight while vulnerable actors in the informal food sector face over-regulation.

When the country went into lockdown on 26 March 2020, government placed the formal food sector at the centre of continued food supply. Informal food vendors were restricted. Yet these vendors provide an important source of food and livelihoods for the majority of South Africa’s population.

Government’s published list of 22 critical products and categories, including 11 basic food items that are price-monitored, does not go far enough to aid the poor, argue leading researchers. Photo: iStock

The South African constitution recognises the right to food. But the government’s failure to enact specific legislation on food rights has resulted in incoherent food security policies.

Even the smallest increases in prices of products in the basic food basket can have a significant impact on poor households and in local markets. Therefore, access to affordable and nutritious food through formal and informal food markets is critical for ensuring people’s right to food.

In this article, we highlight indicators of a distressing rise in the prices of essential food products that is contributing to South Africa’s hunger crisis. We call for the urgent expansion of price controls to items in the basic household food basket, as well as an inquiry into the price-setting of major retailers

Have food prices increased?

Stats SA recently published the headline urban consumer price index (CPI) as having decreased by 0.5% month-on-month in April 2020. But the statistics body explicitly cautioned that its new price collection strategy had been severely limited by the lockdown regulations.

The headline number potentially reflects very different pricing behaviour of major retailers that have an online presence. Moreover, smaller retailers are excluded from this methodology – despite comprising half of poor household food spending based on data from the Income and Expenditure Survey of 2011.

At its core, the right to food is about protecting people’s right to feed themselves.

Evidence of large price increases on essential food items is recorded by the NGO Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity’s price surveys. They find an 8.2% increase in the price of a household food basket for the three-month period from 2 March to 3 June 2020. This includes large increases in the prices of essential food items at the local level over the period, such as an 18% increase for sugar beans and a 14% increase for brown bread.

Comparisons of the Stats SA and Pietermaritzburg surveys are limited by timing and availability of item specific data. But both sources show that prices of brown bread, eggs, potatoes, salt, and soup increased in March and April. These are essential food items not necessarily monitored under current covid-19 regulations.

Why is this not a Competition Commission case?

The price hikes have drawn the attention of the country’s Competition Commission. In a recent food price monitoring report it pointed out significant inflation in the prices of various food items. It commented that, in some cases, the increases and high margins were not justified by the changes in the operating costs of the suppliers.

Regulations introduced in March after the government declared a state of disaster to manage the covid-19 pandemic empowered competition agencies to investigate firms believed to be charging excessive prices for certain essential healthcare and food items. But not a lot has happened.

Although 38% of the 320 complaints received by the Competition Commission by the end of June related to food prices, only one has so far led to an administrative penalty for a firm. This was the Food Lover’s Market case relating to the price of raw ginger.

Cases of excessive pricing of goods and services are among the most difficult to prosecute. This is because of the complexities of determining the extent to which prices are high; relevant cost parameters that have to be considered; the reliability of benchmarks; and the availability of data.

What can be done?

During the most severe part of the lockdown in the country, the government addressed the issue of higher food prices by concluding an agreement with major retailers to limit price increases on key items. But this lapsed immediately after the first easing of the lockdown on 4 May. Since then retailers have increased prices of certain food items in response to higher input prices. We believe a renewed list of price limits should be put in place.

Along with capping price increases for key food items, we propose that the list of items subject to the price monitoring regime be broadened. The Competition Commission’s assessment – and our own – indicate that there has been some positive effect of the food price increase restrictions for food items already included in this list, such as maize meal and frozen chicken. But the published list of 22 critical products and categories, including 11 basic food items that are price-monitored, does not go far enough.

Pictured from the left are researchers Ihsaan Bassier, Refiloe Joala and Dr Thando Vilakazi. Photos: Supplied

The list of 11 food items leaves out brown bread and dried foods such as legumes, for example, which are staple foods for the poor and a major source of nutrition. The inclusion of frozen vegetables, on the other hand, points to poor targeting and a limited understanding of what constitutes the food basket of low-income households. Frozen vegetables are staples among middle-income households.

We recommend the urgent expansion of the list to include brown bread, fresh vegetables, eggs and sugar beans, among other products. A failure to do this may well reverse any positive impact of increasing the rand values of social grants.

While the expansion of social protection measures does in part contribute to access to food for poor and vulnerable households, government should play a role in monitoring and regulating the food sector to ensure a more equitable and sustainable food system for consumers and actors in informal food markets.

Price limits should be complemented by an inquiry into the price-setting of major retailers. The weaknesses in the Stats SA pricing data highlighted above indicate the need for more comprehensive data to inform ongoing monitoring of food prices.

The effects of covid-19 will endure for some time to come, including large-scale job losses, and so it is certainly not too late to intervene. Poorer South African households cannot continue to endure both a crisis of joblessness and food price increases.

  • At Food For Mzansi, we’re big supporters of The Conversation’s Africa edition. This article was originally published by them, and written by Ihsaan Bassier (a PhD candidate in economics at the University of Massachusetts Amherst), Refiloe Joala (researcher and PhD candidate at PLAAS, University of the Western Cape) and Dr Thando Vilakazi (executive director of the centre for competition, regulation and economic development at the University of Johannesburg.)

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • WhatsApp
  • Email
Tags: Competition CommissionCPIcritical food productsDr Thando Vilikazifood price controlshousehold food spendingIhsaan BassierIncome and Expenditure Survey 2011informal food marketsRefiloe JoalaStats SAurban consumer price index
Previous Post

Coetzee’s devotion to nature fuels her passion for farming

Next Post

Grow your agribusiness: The secret of profit vs. cash flow

The Conversation

The Conversation

The Conversation Africa is an independent source of news and views from the academic and research community. Its aim is to promote better understanding of current affairs and complex issues, and allow for a better quality of public discourse and conversation. Go to: https://theconversation.com/africa

Related Posts

Concern as Stats SA reveals a drop in agricultural households

Concern as Stats SA reveals a drop in agricultural households

by Tiisetso Manoko
23rd October 2023
0

The Stats SA Census 2022 report has revealed a drop in agricultural households, namely food gardens, with a lack of...

Census 2022: Farmers cry out for help as pressures intensify

Census 2022: Farmers cry out for help as pressures intensify

by Tiisetso Manoko
11th October 2023
0

It's already a pressure cooker situation for farmers battling many challenges with their day-to-day operations. The rise in South Africa's...

Food prices: Commission investigation is crucial

Food prices: Commission investigation is crucial

by Mahlogedi Thindisa
22nd May 2023
0

An investigation by the Competition Commission into allegations of food price gouging conduct should be welcomed, writes agropreneur and agricultural...

ICYMI: Vegetable prices reaching new heights

ICYMI: Vegetable prices reaching new heights

by Sinenhlanhla Mncwango
28th April 2023
0

Consumers are paying more for essential foods than ever before. The Consumer Price Index for March shows that vegetable prices...

Next Post
Bertie Hamman of Standard Bank chats to Dawn Noemdoe of Food For Mzansi about profit vs cash flow

Grow your agribusiness: The secret of profit vs. cash flow

News

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

by Team Food For Mzansi
1st December 2023
0

Farmers share their gratitude towards Food For Mzansi for paving the way forward as they build their farming enterprises. From...

Read more
Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

1st December 2023
Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

1st December 2023
ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

1st December 2023
Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

1st December 2023

Jacobs Jam triumphs: SMME winner at Shoprite Awards

CPAs need good governance for private-sector land reform support

Rural resilience: Women in farming project triumphs

ICYMI: Sparks fly during tobacco bill hearings across SA

From hardier goats to flood resilience, climate adaptation is key

This week’s agri events: 27 November-01 December

RSS From FoodForAfrika.com

  • $2 Million investment in fertiliser financing for Kenyan smallholders
  • AfDB empowers Tanzanian horticulture with $2.5m boost
  • Malagasy scientist wins $150k grant

THE NEW FACE OF SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE

With 15 global awards in the first four years of its existence, Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication. It is a movement, unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture. We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society.

Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

Bureau Veritas goes solar at Cape Town agrifood lab

Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

  • Our Story
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright

Contact us
Office: +27 21 879 1824
News: info@foodformzansi.co.za
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
Login

Copyright © 2021 Food for Mzansi

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.