As the discussions on land reform continue, the big question from experts and those who receive land is how to keep the land profitable and ensure it becomes a success.
Brian Whittaker and Mazwi Mkhulisi of the nonprofit organisation Vumelana Advisory Fund argued that good governance and community-private partnerships (CPPs) can attract investment, create employment and generate income for land reform beneficiary communities.
Whittaker and Mkhulisi draw on case studies from CPAs in Mpumalanga, the Eastern Cape, the North West and Limpopo, highlighting restored land ranging from 639 to 26 000 hectares.
How the partnerships benefit rural communities
The CPP model, pioneered by Vumelana over a decade ago, connects land reform beneficiary communities organised into communal property associations (CPAs) with private investors to make restored land productive, economically viable and sustainable.
Typically, communities contribute land and receive rental income, employment opportunities and dividends, while private partners provide capital and skills. The model seeks to address the persistent absence of adequate post-settlement support.
Returning the land to communities is only one part of land reform. Without investment, technical expertise, access to markets and effective governance, restored land becomes unproductive, leaving beneficiaries unable to develop sustainable livelihoods.
Whittaker argues that partnerships with appropriate safeguards, accountability mechanisms and community participation have improved livelihoods and created economic opportunities.
“The case studies covered restored land ranging from 639 to 26 000 hectares, with commercial partners ranging from family-owned businesses to multi-billion-rand global enterprises. Partnerships involved long-term leases of between 23 and 49 years, most with share options enabling communities to acquire an equity stake.
“In agricultural projects, assets remained with community landowners, while tourism agreements provided for assets to be returned to communities at the end of the lease,” Vumelana Advisory Fund said in a statement.
Related stories
- Minister launches R1.2b land reform programme to support farmers
- High input costs threaten land reform success
- Nyhontso outlines billions to boost land reform and viability
- SA agriculture sheds 34 000 jobs as input costs squeeze farmers
According to the organisation, the rent earned by the CPAs ranged from R750 000 to several million Rand per annum, while dividends and fees ranged from R800 000 to R12.2 million per annum. Salaries and wages, accounted for over 80% of the benefit in some cases. Communities also benefited from training, skills development and procurement opportunities.
“Surveys found that the income of community members increased by between 30% and 90% compared with those who were not employed in the projects.
“They also helped accelerate financial inclusion, with beneficiaries gaining greater access to bank accounts and credit facilities as well as improved access to education and skills, while reducing dependence on social grants and the need for families to withdraw children from school or skip meals when funds ran low,” Vumelana Advisory Fund stated.
Addressing the post-settlement challenges of land reform
Transaction advisors play a crucial role in facilitating these partnerships by providing independent advice and negotiating fair agreements that protect the interests of both parties and deliver mutual benefits.
Without independent transaction advisory support, communities risk entering into unfavourable agreements that could undermine the sustainability of these partnerships. When partnerships collapse, the consequences extend beyond the immediate parties, resulting in unproductive land, unemployment and renewed demands for government support.
Mkhulisi said that in one of the cases, the introduction of an independent transaction advisor helped the community secure R70 million in new investment, increase rental income by R80 million over the lease term and improve its shareholding from 40% to 50%, and employment opportunities increased from 150 to 250.
In another case, a community that renegotiated an agreement without independent advice lost substantial contractual rights previously secured with an advisor’s assistance.
Mkhulisi highlighted that while independent transaction advice is essential to the success of CPPs, the financial realities of land reform make it difficult for private advisors to provide these services on a commercial basis.
With about one-third of engagements resulting in successful transactions, from which fees can be recovered, there is a funding gap, which would most appropriately be filled by public funding.
“While commercial partnerships are not a panacea for the challenges facing land reform, the Vumelana experience shows that they offer a practical avenue for addressing the post-settlement dilemma.
“Government can help make these partnerships more widely available by providing public funding for independent transaction advisory services so that communities do not have to negotiate alone,” Whittaker said.
READ NEXT: Free State agripreneur represents SA at China seminar






