• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
There is an extreme lack of transparency when it comes to the South African pesticide market, found a team of global researchers. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Bayer pesticides ‘damaging health of SA farmworkers’

24th May 2021
Dr Peter Oberem (right), the founder of Afrivet Southern Africa, with Ronan Smith, Bimeda’s chief executive for the Africa, Middle East and Asia Pacific division. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Bimeda’s Afrivet takeover ‘to strengthen animal health offering’

17th August 2022
Agriculture, land reform and rural development minister Thoko Didiza has placed a 21-day ban on the movement of cattle across South Africa due to foot-and-mouth disease (FMD) outbreaks. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

SA battles 116 FMD outbreaks amid 21-day cattle ban

16th August 2022
ADVERTISEMENT
Illegal sand mining poses a threat to many ecosystems, human safety and agricultural practises. Photo: Pixabay

Will the world run out of sand?

16th August 2022
Organic certification is a long, but rewarding process. Photo: Supplied/Food for Mzansi

How to get the ball rolling on organic certification

16th August 2022
This #SoilSista’s poultry farm puts quality first

This #SoilSista’s poultry farm puts quality first

16th August 2022
Prof. Theo Venter gives his take on the ruling party’s recent policy conference and what it means going forward. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Fixing agri challenges: ‘ANC no longer has a choice’

16th August 2022
The Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development, Ms. Thoko Didiza, MP has taken the decision to suspend all movement of cattle in the whole country. The Ministers decision is aimed at halting the continued spread of Foot and Mouth Disease in the country. It also means that cattle may not be moved from one property to another for any reason for a period of 21 days reviewable weekly. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

FMD battle: Govt prohibits movement of all cattle

16th August 2022
Justin Platt, founder and CEO of Zylem and RegenZ argues that instead of basing management decisions on a purely rational and cognitive approach, farmers need to harness (and trust) their unique intuition. Photo: Supply/AdobeStock

Farmers, trust your intuition and go with your gut

16th August 2022
Leanne Gammage and Jackson Andrew, co-founders of Masterstock Cape Wild Food. Masterstock Cape Wild Food is a speciality salt brand focused on regenerative agriculture. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Agripreneur 101: Regeneration at the heart of this salt company

16th August 2022

R350 grant puts sisters on agri path to success

15th August 2022
The uMngeni Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal is supporting local farmers through a new agricultural unit that has been established in the municipality. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Farmer support: KZN municipality leads the way

15th August 2022
Farmers in the south-western parts of the country can expect a slightly drier than usual spring. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

ICYMI: Below-normal winter rainfall to continue

15th August 2022
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
11 GLOBAL MEDIA AWARDS
Wednesday, August 17, 2022
Food For Mzansi
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
    • All
    • AgriCareers
    • Entrepreneurs
    • Farmers
    • Groundbreakers
    • Innovators
    • Inspiration
    • It Takes a Village
    • Mentors
    • Movers and Shakers
    • Partnerships
    Leanne Gammage and Jackson Andrew, co-founders of Masterstock Cape Wild Food. Masterstock Cape Wild Food is a speciality salt brand focused on regenerative agriculture. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Agripreneur 101: Regeneration at the heart of this salt company

    R350 grant puts sisters on agri path to success

    The uMngeni Municipality in KwaZulu-Natal is supporting local farmers through a new agricultural unit that has been established in the municipality. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Farmer support: KZN municipality leads the way

    This drone is collecting data which farmers can then access on the yield management platform. Photo: Supplied/Aerobotics

    How the Internet of Things is transforming agri

    His life took a turn for the worst when he ended up in jail for dealing in drugs, but Thembinkosi Matika turned his life around and now helps others through his Legacy Farming Project. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Drug dealer turned farmer ploughs back

    Christo Van der Rheede is the executive director of Agri SA. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Former music teacher leads agri’s greatest symphony

    Agripreneur 101: Creating a beauty brand

    Agripreneur 101: Creating a beauty brand

    Claire and Martin Joubert have sacrificed and struggled to become top breeders of Ankole cattle in South Africa. But giving up was never an option, because they wanted to offer only the very best Ankole genetics in the country. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Farming couple lives and breathes Ankole cattle

    Tackling climate change, one tree at a time

  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
No Result
View All Result
Food For Mzansi

Bayer pesticides ‘damaging health of SA farmworkers’

by Sinesipho Tom
24th May 2021
in News
Reading Time: 8 mins read
A A
There is an extreme lack of transparency when it comes to the South African pesticide market, found a team of global researchers. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

There is an extreme lack of transparency when it comes to the South African pesticide market, found a team of global researchers. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Bayer has hit back at research that claims it is developing and selling highly hazardous pesticide-active ingredients that are damaging the health of farmworkers and farmers in South Africa, Brazil and Mexico.

Responding to enquiries by Food For Mzansi the chief executive of Bayer Southern Africa and cluster head for Crop Science Africa, Dr Klaus Eckstein, affirmed its commitment to “developing and stewarding products that both fulfil high safety standards and meet the unique needs of farmers”.

A new study, “Double standards and hazardous pesticides from Bayer and BASF,” has shocked the global agricultural sector with its glimpse behind the scenes of the international trade in pesticide active ingredients. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi
A new study, “Double standards and hazardous pesticides from Bayer and BASF,” has shocked the global agricultural sector with its glimpse behind the scenes of the international trade in pesticide active ingredients. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

This, after the shocking findings of a 2020 report by the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung, the INKOTA-netzwerk and PAN Germany. The researchers include Peter Clausing, Lena Luig and Jan Urhahn.

They found that Bayer and BASF are both responsible for the marketing, and in some cases, also the development of at least 33 pesticide-active ingredients that pose a distinct threat to human health.

Many of these active ingredients are lethal even at low doses, and others are considered likely to be cancer-causing, interfering with human production and capable of inducing heritable genetic defects or increasing their incidence.

In Mzansi, as well as the two South American countries, at least eight of these active ingredients can be found in the pesticide portfolios of Bayer and BASF.

Banned in the EU, but still sold in SA

This includes glufosinate and spirodiclofen. Glufosinate has a reprotoxic classification due to it causing still births, miscarriages, and premature births in animal studies that were legally conducted by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA).

Spirodiclofen was classified as carcinogenic by the ECHA in 2016 for causing liver tumours in a cancer study on mice as well as testicular tumours and carcinoma of the uterus in a study on rats.

In South Africa, the two German agrochemical companies market at least 28 active ingredients in South Africa and Brazil that are not approved in the European Union (EU) because of the severe associated health risks. Of this, BASF sells 13 and Bayer 15, found the researchers.

Among them are epoxiconazole, ethoprophos, glufosinate, and thiacloprid which are imported from China, and fenamiphos from the United States. Each of these either affect the reproductive system or the embryo or cause difficult or laboured breathing and slowness of the heart.

Dr Klaus Eckstein, CEO of Bayer Southern Africa and Cluster Head for Crop Science Africa. Photo: Supplied/ Food For Mzansi
Dr Klaus Eckstein, CEO of Bayer Southern Africa and Cluster Head for Crop Science Africa. Photo: Supplied/ Food For Mzansi

However, Eckstein tells Food For Mzansi “to take specific country requirements into account, we cannot take a ‘one size fits all’ approach to developing, registering, and selling our agricultural solutions around the world.

“And when it comes to crop protection, our commitment is to only sell products that clear our own robust internal safety assessments and also meet the safety standards of the respective local regulators, including South Africa.”

According to Eckstein “it is not automatically a double standard if we export crop protection products that are manufactured, but not registered in Europe to other countries”.

Lethal even in small doses

The German researchers found that many Western Cape wine farms use Bayer’s Tempo SC, an insecticide, on large scale. The product contains the highly hazardous active ingredient (beta-cyfluthrin), which is lethal even in small doses. Symptoms may include irritation of the eyes, skin, and respiratory tract.

On some farms, farmworkers are sent into the vineyards while these highly hazardous pesticides are being sprayed in the fields.

According to the researchers the mixing of pesticides at many farms takes place without any protective equipment, and the pesticides often spill and are not disposed of properly. The authors of this study were told that some farmers force workers to remove the labels from the packaging. This then makes it difficult for the inspectors to establish misuse of pesticides when they come.

“Please note that Tempo SC is an insecticide commercialised by our environmental science business in South Africa for the control of indoor and outdoor hygiene pests. It is also commercialised in other countries like the US,” says Eckstein.

Although Bayer made a public commitment in 2013 to no longer market active ingredients of high acute toxicity, this continues to happen. In South Africa 9 000 different pesticide products are registered in the country, according to Luig et. al.

SA is a global pesticide hub

In recent years, the number of pesticide products and active ingredients that were imported to South Africa, as well as the number exported from South Africa to neighbouring countries, dramatically increased. Between 2008 and 2018, the value of imports has nearly doubled from approximately $239 million to more than $465 million.

The annual volume of pesticides imported to South Africa grew from approximately 37 900 tonnes to 74 800 tonnes. Over the same period, the value of pesticide exports from South Africa grew from $122 million to $266 million. This indicates an increase from approximately 23 400 tonnes to 45 400 tonnes

“It is a misleading assumption that products not registered in the EU are unsafe to use outside the EU,” says Eckstein. “We have different pest and disease spectrums in Africa as well as climatic and environmental conditions which requires to take local circumstances into account when providing solutions to farmers which are in many ways different to that in the EU.”

Agrochemical companies Bayer and BASF are accused of marketing and, in some cases, developing at least 33 pesticide active ingredients that pose an acute threat to human health. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi
Agrochemical companies Bayer and BASF are accused of marketing and, in some cases, developing at least 33 pesticide active ingredients that pose an acute threat to human health. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

‘Safe if properly applied’

Eckstein says Bayer’s crop protection products are tested, developed and registered across the globe and found to be safe, if used according to the label instructions.

“It is important that these products are available to ensure the development of farmers (smallholders and commercial) in Africa and making them part of food value chains as part of a sustainable and profitable business where they can grow and contribute to communities and countries.”

Currently, the EU forbids the manufacturing, storage and marketing of pesticide products that contain active ingredients that are not approved in its 27 member states due to health or environmental concerns.

The researchers believe these pesticide products are still being exported to South Africa because the regulations regarding imported hazardous pesticides in the country are considered “relaxed”.

While both Bayer and BASF maintain that their products are safe if they are properly applied, it does not bear in mind that, in many cases, the necessary protective equipment is not available or often expensive and/or considered impractical for South African conditions. Farmworkers have described their protective clothing merely decorative, say the researchers.

Some farmers are unable to understand the information listed on the packaging regarding the application of the products.

The pesticide manufacturers are well aware of all this, warn the researchers. Ultimately, they take advantage of the weaker regulations in the countries of the global South in order to make profits with highly hazardous pesticides at the expense of humans and the environment.

A poisonous sector

To date, 385 million people worldwide suffer from acute pesticide poisoning annually, compared to an estimated 25 million cases in 1990. This means that approximately 44% of the people who work in agriculture worldwide, including farmers and their workers, suffer from poisoning every year.

Meanwhile Eckstein tells Food For Mzansi the Bayer Crop Science Division recently published its internal safety standards for crop protection products.

“We are the first company to make these criteria available to the public. We are calling for industry-wide self-regulation and transparency to increase the impact of the initiative.”

The global team of researchers recommend that the South African government pass a law prohibiting the import of active ingredients and pesticide products that are not approved in the EU or other countries. Also, they believe should ban the trade and use of highly hazardous pesticides, as defined by the Pesticide Action Network.

ALSO READ: Permaculture: 12 principles to farm like Mother Nature

Tags: BASFBayerDr Klaus EcksteinEuropean Chemicals Agency (ECHA)FarmersfarmworkersLiza Bohlmannpesticide
Previous Post

When dreams came to nothing, her garden fed more than just her body

Next Post

2021 wine grape harvest deemed to be excellent

Sinesipho Tom

Sinesipho Tom

Sinesipho Tom is an audience engagement journalist at Food for Mzansi. Before joining the team, she worked in financial and business news at Media24. She has an appetite for news reporting and has written articles for Business Insider, Fin24 and Parent 24. If you could describe Sinesipho in a sentence you would say that she is a small-town girl with big, big dreams.

Related Posts

Queues of farmworkers in search of their Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) benefits snake around the block at the satellite department of labour office in De Doorns near Worcester in the Western Cape. Photo: Liezl Human/GroundUp

Seasonal farmworkers struggle to get UIF

by GroundUp
8th August 2022
0

In case you missed it: Even after a "rapid response team" tried to help clear up a backlog at the...

Gray Maguire from Carbon Neutral Group South Africa. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Podcast: Level up your farm with carbon credits

by Vateka Halile
7th August 2022
0

FARMER'S INSIDE TRACK: Gray Maguire from the Carbon Neutral Group South Africa, explains the benefits of farmers signing up for...

The Western Cape High Court has ruled in favour of Eric Lolo who went to court to hold the Drakenstein Municipality accountable for emergency housing for people evicted from farms. Photo: Barbara Maregele/GroundUp

ICYMI: High Court victory for former farmworker

by GroundUp
4th August 2022
0

In case you missed it: In a case brought by a former farmworker, the Western Cape High Court told the...

A traditional healer claims to have discovered the bodies of two parents and their three children on the Toekoms farm outside Harrismith in the Free State. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Police vow to find seven farmworkers’ killers

by Tiisetso Manoko
19th July 2022
0

Prompted by provincial police commissioner Baile Motswenyane, a manhunt is on for the murderers of six women and one young...

Next Post
Fruit, not only from Nederburg itself but from its supplier farms across the Western Cape, came into the cellars in remarkably healthy, crisp conditions. Photo: Supplied/Nederburg

2021 wine grape harvest deemed to be excellent

Organic certification is a long, but rewarding process. Photo: Supplied/Food for Mzansi
Farmer's Inside Track

How to get the ball rolling on organic certification

by Nicole Ludolph
16th August 2022
0

FARMER'S INSIDE TRACK: Organic certification poses a challenge to many South African farmers who go that route. Alan Rosenberg, chairperson...

Read more
This #SoilSista’s poultry farm puts quality first

This #SoilSista’s poultry farm puts quality first

16th August 2022
Prof. Theo Venter gives his take on the ruling party’s recent policy conference and what it means going forward. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Fixing agri challenges: ‘ANC no longer has a choice’

16th August 2022
The Minister of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development, Ms. Thoko Didiza, MP has taken the decision to suspend all movement of cattle in the whole country. The Ministers decision is aimed at halting the continued spread of Foot and Mouth Disease in the country. It also means that cattle may not be moved from one property to another for any reason for a period of 21 days reviewable weekly. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

FMD battle: Govt prohibits movement of all cattle

16th August 2022
Justin Platt, founder and CEO of Zylem and RegenZ argues that instead of basing management decisions on a purely rational and cognitive approach, farmers need to harness (and trust) their unique intuition. Photo: Supply/AdobeStock

Farmers, trust your intuition and go with your gut

16th August 2022

Drug dealer turned farmer ploughs back

Fruit farm shows there’s power in transformation

R350 grant puts sisters on agri path to success

FMD battle: Govt prohibits movement of all cattle

Former music teacher leads agri’s greatest symphony

This week’s agriculture events: 15 to 18 August 2022

THE NEW FACE OF SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE

With 12 global awards in the first three years of its existence, Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication. It is a movement, unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture. We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society.

Bimeda’s Afrivet takeover ‘to strengthen animal health offering’

SA battles 116 FMD outbreaks amid 21-day cattle ban

Will the world run out of sand?

How to get the ball rolling on organic certification

This #SoilSista’s poultry farm puts quality first

Fixing agri challenges: ‘ANC no longer has a choice’

  • Our Story
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright

Contact us
Office: +27 21 879 1824
News: info@foodformzansi.co.za
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought

Copyright © 2021 Food for Mzansi

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.