• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
‘Mr Ramaphosa, farmers don’t fear land reform, they fear policy uncertainty’

‘Mr Ramaphosa, farmers don’t fear land reform, they fear policy uncertainty’

11th May 2021
Dr Harry Malila, Head of Department and Accounting Officer for the Department of the Premier, Mayor Alderman Franken and minister of agriculture Ivan Meyer showing off freshly made sausage and patti. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Mobile factory brings agri-processing to rural farmers

21st May 2022
Lauren Strever of amorentia sweet dragon fruit estate and Nursery, Micheal Muller of Muller familie boerdery trust and Stephen Mantsho of the South African avocado growers association. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Farmer 101: Holy guacemole! Growing avos worth a try

20th May 2022
The North West department of agriculture and rural development has been allocated a budget of R1.2 billion to spend in the new financial year. However, they have days to report back on how exactly they plant to use this money. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Portfolio committee not letting NW officials off the hook

20th May 2022

This chef is taking fine dining in Kimberley to the top

20th May 2022

Recipe: Butternut soup to go absolutely nuts for

20th May 2022
Gavin Kelly, chief executive officer of the Road Freight Association, says operating costs within the road freight and logistics sector have increased exponentially. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Perfect fuel storm in the road freight, logistics industry

20th May 2022
A burning passion for education and agriculture made it easy for Evelyn Fisher to fulfil her aspirations in the form of an agri academy. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Starting her agri academy a lifelong dream fulfilled

20th May 2022
Conference of the Parties (COP15) of the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD) concludes today (Friday, 20 May). Global leaders are hoping for clear commitments on drought resilience and soil restoration before delegates head home. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

UN land conference: Soil, drought, gender top the talks

20th May 2022
Minister Ebrahim Patel has the eyes of the sugar industry on him as he delivers the department of trade, industry and competition's budget. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

‘Patel, don’t forget sugarcane Master Plan commitments’

20th May 2022
Pietermaritzburg farmer Andile Ngcobo counted among the thousands of visitors to Nampo. To allow for reduced daily capacity amid Covid-19 restrictions, the expo is held over a period of five days. Under the theme “Experience it”, organisers gave visitors a broad overview of the latest trends, equipment, vehicles and so much more offered to the agriculture sector. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

In pictures: Big toys (and smiles!) at Nampo

19th May 2022
Winter weather is coming, and farmers are advised to stay informed and to prepared as best they could to safeguard their fields and animals. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Weather warning: ‘Be extra cautious for pests, diseases’

20th May 2022
Kenyan president Uhuru Kenyatta has announced that Kenya will now be using agricultural land from parastatals and giving it to private companies to prioritise the production of food and cash crops. Photo: Supplied/Unsplash

Kenya to hand over land to private companies

19th May 2022
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
11 GLOBAL MEDIA AWARDS
Sun, May 22, 2022
Food For Mzansi
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
    • All
    • AgriCareers
    • Entrepreneurs
    • Farmers
    • Groundbreakers
    • Innovators
    • Inspiration
    • It Takes a Village
    • Mentors
    • Movers and Shakers
    • Partnerships
    A burning passion for education and agriculture made it easy for Evelyn Fisher to fulfil her aspirations in the form of an agri academy. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Starting her agri academy a lifelong dream fulfilled

    Driving local food security through research

    InnoFoodAfrica project brings food security home

    Iris Telmaggiers (fright), Sophie Sauir and Leoni Pasja harvesting green peppers from Sauir’s garden. Photo: Siphokazi Mnyobe

    Vegetable garden helps Iris cope with son’s death

    Agripreneur 101: Balance is key for this cannabis skincare producer

    Agripreneur 101: Meet a cannabis skincare producer

    Dr Obvious Mapiye, whose studies helped develop new livestock management software. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Dr Mapiye’s driven to help small-scale farmers commercialise

    Paballo Khoza is harvesting lettuce on his 6 000 square metre shade-netted farm in Westonaria Agri-Park. Photo: Magnificent Mndebele/Food For Mzansi

    Sweat, tears and dreadful walks: Khoza finally triumphs

    ‘Dream, then pursue it,’ urges tomato farmer

    Thabo Skhosana an emerging farmer in Newcastle in KwaZulu-Natal wants to motivate young farmers who wants to study agriculture. Photo: Supplied/ Food For Mzansi

    ‘The future is ours for the taking,’ says young farmer

    Agripreneur: Learn from a cannabis skincare producer

    Agripreneur: Learn from a cannabis skincare producer

  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
No Result
View All Result
Food For Mzansi
Home News

‘Mr Ramaphosa, farmers don’t fear land reform, they fear policy uncertainty’

by Staff Reporter
11th May 2021
in News
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
‘Mr Ramaphosa, farmers don’t fear land reform, they fear policy uncertainty’

President Cyril Ramaphosa met with farmers at the Beyerskloof wine farm in Stellenbosch. Photo: ANC

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

An agricultural business leader has pleaded with Cyril Ramaphosa to urgently give certainty with regards to South Africa’s land reform policy following the president’s meeting with farmers in Stellenbosch as part of his pre-election drive.

Elton Greeve, the Managing Director of EMG Agri Solutions, is a former Chief Director: Strategic Land Reform Interventions in the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. He says as a black South African he was moved by Ramaphosa’s call on white farmers to not fear land reform. Ramaphosa pleaded with white South Africans to not leave the country in search of greener pastures.

Elton Greeve, the Managing Director of EMG Agri Solutions.

The president addressed farmers at the Beyerskloof wine farm in the Western Cape, saying: “I can assure you that the land reform process is something we should never fear. It is to be done in accordance with the rule of law and the Constitution. It is not going to be land grabs where land is grabbed outside of the parameters of law.”

ADVERTISEMENT

In an open letter addressed to the president, Greeve describes this as a “bold and noble statement”. However, he is convinced that farmers are not actually fearing land reform, “but the process and manner in which it is undertaken, and the uncertainty it creates when policy isn’t clear, implementation is haphazard, or statements made around the proposals on ‘expropriation without compensation’ (are made)”.

Food For Mzansi publishes the full text of Greeve’s letter below, with his permission. The letter was submitted to the presidency as well as the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform. Should we receive a response, we will update this story with their responses.

Elton Greeve’s open letter to Cyril Ramaphosa

Dear Mr President,

I write this letter to you in the hope that it serves as a way forward towards making South Africa, and more so the agricultural sector a unified, and prosperous one. Mr President, I watched with interest your engagements with farmers and stakeholders in the Western Cape on 9 April 2019 and must commend the spirit in which the engagements were conducted.

During the discussions and your address to the event Mr President, you indicated that “white farmers must not fear land reform”, which is a bold and noble statement, and which one must admire. However, Mr President, I am of the opinion that it is not land reform that farmers fear, but the process and manner in which it is undertaken, and the uncertainty it creates when policy isn’t clear, implementation is haphazard, or statements made around the proposals on ‘expropriation without compensation’.

As a black South African, I have had engagements with many farmers, both black and white, and all are willing and able to contribute towards making land reform work, both from a private sector perspective, as well as working with government. In order to make this work, there must be change, and I base this on the following.

A few years ago, the government called for white commercial farmers to partner with their workers and the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, on the Strengthening of the Relative Rights of Those Working the Land Programme, many commercial farmers submitted proposals, and subsequently projects were implemented.

SONA 2019: President Cyril Ramaphosa Photo: GovernmentZA
President Cyril Ramaphosa Photo: GovernmentZA

It is however not all rosy, Mr President, and one can only hope that by your call to cut bureaucracy and improve governance, the situation with these projects and land reform in general will change.

It is in this spirit that I draft this letter.

ADVERTISEMENT

Allow me the opportunity to highlight what has happened, and I do so in the spirit of improving how things are done, and how we can move forward in a more pragmatic and solution driven spirit for land reform.

I want to focus in on three projects, as examples, one in the Western Cape and two in the Free State, I will not mention the projects names, as they have already been victimised enough by the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform.

ADVERTISEMENT

Land Reform Project 1, Western Cape

This was approved in 2016, and the deal was structured for commercial farmers to partner with their workers in a shareholding arrangement, land was acquired, and the project commenced. All good and well, until it came time for the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform to provide its share of the operating capital. To date, as I draft this letter, this has not happened.

In turn, Mr President, the response from the Department has been criticism, character assassinations and a myriad of excuses. (All available in writing should your office wish to scrutinise these.)

What are the consequences of the Departments actions/inaction, and the unwillingness to contribute the operating capital?

  • Workers can’t be paid as the project has no funding to operate.
  • The project is at a standstill due to this. Files of correspondence sent to the Department were met with either no response or a response of criticism and a blame-game.
  • The beneficiaries, who were supposed to benefit from this project have been left destitute, unable to pay schools, buy the basic necessities and has left their households in distress – this is the opposite of what this project envisaged.

Land Reform Project 2, based in the Free State

This followed the same route as project 1, but was approved in 2017. Again, the Department has not complied with its agreement to provide operating capital to the project, although this was agreed upon in writing when the project was approved and implemented. To date, two years later the project is in jeopardy.

The project has sent numerous correspondence to the Department, but this has either been ignored, or responses are based on accusations towards the partners within the project. The Department has further opted to isolate the project rather than engage with it. Again, it is the workers who are suffering due to the inactions of the Department. In project 1 and 2, the Department and National Empowerment Fund have been engaged in a struggle against each other, each apportioning blame against the other for the above situation. (Noting that the NEF was the implementing agent for the Department on these projects.)

Winemaker Beyers Truter, President Cyril Ramaphosa and Gert Oosthuizen, Deputy Minister of Sport and Recreation.

Land Reform Project 3, also in the Free State

A farmer sells a portion of his farm to the Department, in return he forms a business partnership with his workers. The land was acquired in 2016, and 3 years later, the project still awaits the finalisation of the land transfer to the beneficiaries in terms of the Extension of Security of Tenure Act.

It took ten months to register a Communal Property Association in whose title the land will be held. To date, the land has still not been transferred to the CPA. What this means, is that he project has been on hold since 2016 and could not produce anything.

Mr President, I support your call to cut bureaucracy, it will go a long way towards easing the burden of undertaking projects with government, this within the land reform process. I understand there has to be processes, but surely such processes should not take years, and in turn disrupt agricultural businesses.

The governing party took a resolution that land reform should not be undertaken in a manner that disrupts the agricultural sector or production, the above examples demonstrate that it the opposite was done. Mr President, the intention is not to criticise, but in the process of change one has to identify the problem, admit that there’s a problem, and then remedy such.

Farmers listening to President Cyril Ramaphosa during his visit to Stellenbosch in the Western Cape.

Thus, I send this letter to you in the hope that it highlights some of the challenges, and paves a way forward to address these, but also in the hope that by assisting you and supporting you in your call for change – that we can make a difference together as a sector.

Lastly Mr President, I served in government for 20 years, namely in the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, I resigned in 2017 as I could not handle the toxic work environment, I could also not sit by and watch a process unfold which was turning land reform into a counter-productive process.

Many other senior officials subsequently left the department, also having served 20 or more years in the Department. This is the reality of how a department operates, to the extent that Senior Officials with decades of experience and institutional knowledge left the Department. My commitment now resides in utilising my experience (from a private sector approach) to assist the agricultural sector make a difference, even though mine is or might be a small one, but it is a contribution, nonetheless.

Mr President, land reform can work, but it must be done in a manner that is efficient, effective and responsible.

Mr President, Thuma Mina!

Yours sincerely,

Elton Greeve

  • Also read a young, aspiring farmer’s open letter: Send us, Mr Ramaphosa, a new generation of farmers.
Tags: ANCBeyers TruterBeyerskloofBreaking newsCyril RamaphosaDepartment of Rural Development and Land Reformelectionland expropriation without compensationland reform
Share196Tweet123Send
Staff Reporter

Staff Reporter

Researched and written by our team of writers and editors.

Related Posts

The Mamphodo Mushasha Begwa Community Property Association (CPA) located in Louis Trichadt and Elim in Limpopo has been crushed by alleged sabotage. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

‘Sabotage’ brings successful land reform farm to its knees

by Staff Reporter
18th May 2022
0

What seemed like textbook example of a successful land reform farm in Limpopo has been brought to its knees, allegedly...

Some of the agriculture events to look out for this week includes the second Kaallaagte cattle auction as well as training in worm farming. Photos: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

This week’s agriculture events: 9 May – 13 April

by Vateka Halile
9th May 2022
0

This week's agri calendar is jam-packed with exciting activities such as a livestock auction, webinar on the Agri food industry,...

Farmers and agri leaders reflect on what Freedom Day means, 28 years after Mzansi's first democratic elections. Photos: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Freedom Day: Black farmers still fighting for a dream

by Zolani Sinxo
27th Apr 2022
0

It's Freedom Day. As the country commemorates this important day in the history of South Africa, black farmers tell Food...

Floods in KwaZulu-Natal have caused great economic and social damage, and the state of the Durban port has export farmers worried. Photo: Supplied

KZN floods: Durban port has export farmers worried

by Duncan Masiwa
19th Apr 2022
0

His message to growers was to expect the unexpected in 2022, but he never thought he would see containers drifting...

Mzansi Flavour

This chef is taking fine dining in Kimberley to the top

by Noluthando Ngcakani
20th May 2022
0

She started her career in the food industry as a waiter, but now chef Nelly Engelbrecht is wowing diners with...

Read more

Recipe: Butternut soup to go absolutely nuts for

20th May 2022
Gavin Kelly, chief executive officer of the Road Freight Association, says operating costs within the road freight and logistics sector have increased exponentially. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Perfect fuel storm in the road freight, logistics industry

20th May 2022
A burning passion for education and agriculture made it easy for Evelyn Fisher to fulfil her aspirations in the form of an agri academy. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Starting her agri academy a lifelong dream fulfilled

20th May 2022
Conference of the Parties (COP15) of the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD) concludes today (Friday, 20 May). Global leaders are hoping for clear commitments on drought resilience and soil restoration before delegates head home. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

UN land conference: Soil, drought, gender top the talks

20th May 2022

This chef is taking fine dining in Kimberley to the top

In pictures: Big toys (and smiles!) at Nampo

Roads in disrepair: Farmers count the ‘wasted’ costs

Kenya to hand over land to private companies

Mobile factory brings agri-processing to rural farmers

All you need to know about growing avocados

THE NEW FACE OF SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE

With 11 global awards in the first three years of its existence, Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication. It is a movement, unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture. We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society.

Mobile factory brings agri-processing to rural farmers

Farmer 101: Holy guacemole! Growing avos worth a try

Portfolio committee not letting NW officials off the hook

This chef is taking fine dining in Kimberley to the top

Recipe: Butternut soup to go absolutely nuts for

Perfect fuel storm in the road freight, logistics industry

  • Our Story
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright

Contact us
Office: +27 21 879 1824
WhatsApp line: +27 81 889 9032
Marketing: +27 71 147 0388
News: info@foodformzansi.co.za
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought

Copyright © 2021 Food for Mzansi

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Go to mobile version