Food For Mzansi assistant editor Duncan Masiwa shines a spotlight on the contentious role of middlemen in agriculture. Recent scandals reveal how these intermediaries, meant to support farmers, often exploit their positions. Are they more trouble than they’re worth?
The role of middlemen in South Africa’s agricultural sector has once again come under scrutiny, and for good reason. In recent times, it has become clear that not all middlemen act in the best interest of farmers and the sector as a whole, which raises an important question: does their presence do more harm than good?
For starters, I must point out that this is not the first time this particular question has been asked. Many stakeholders in the sector have raised it in the past. And when you consider the more than 25 dairy farmers who were cheated out of R90 million by Desmanda Milk, this question becomes very relevant once again.
While this incident shows us what can go wrong, we need to weigh up both the good and bad sides of middlemen in farming.
Why intermediaries matter
Farming is really complex, and it’s tough for farmers to handle everything on their own. That’s where middlemen come in. They handle the tough parts like processing, packing, transporting, and selling crops. This lets farmers focus on farming and managing their land.
For example, a middleman might collect milk from several dairy farms, ensure it is pasteurised and packaged, and then distribute it to supermarkets.
Middlemen help farmers reach bigger markets outside their local area, so they can sell to more people. They use their connections and distribution channels to help farmers sell their crops or get the supplies they need for their farms.
When you think about all this, it seems clear that middlemen are crucial for farmers and for agriculture in general. So, how is it that they could end up causing more harm than good?
Well, while middlemen can provide farmers with access to larger markets and enable them to focus on farming rather than logistics, their role also comes with risks.
The Desmanda Milk case is a stark reminder of these risks, as the company’s financial collapse left farmers without payment for their produce, highlighting the potential for middlemen to cause significant harm when they fail to meet their obligations.
The court papers revealed that Desmanda Milk had assets of R612 million against liabilities of R867 million, leaving no chance of turning the business around. This means the farmers who trusted the company, some for a long time, are now in a tough spot financially and might not get their money back.
This is especially tough for dairy farmers who already face high costs just to keep their farms running. Missing payments for milk produced could be devastating, possibly forcing farms that have been around for decades to shut down. This shows how much damage middlemen can do.
Weighing the harm and the good
However, middlemen are not inherently detrimental to the agricultural sector. As mentioned above, they often play a crucial role in providing access to markets, products, and services that many South African farmers would otherwise struggle to reach.
This was evident during the Covid-19 pandemic when President Cyril Ramaphosa launched his presidential stimulus package. Part of this package included Pesi vouchers, which were a lifeline for many small-scale and subsistence farmers on the brink of closure.
These vouchers enabled farmers to purchase essential agricultural inputs, thereby sustaining their operations during a period of extreme uncertainty. Middlemen, in this context, made sure these vital resources reached all affected and qualifying farmers.
Without them, many small farmers and community gardens might not have survived the economic problems caused by the pandemic.
Despite the clear benefits, the involvement of middlemen in the Pesi voucher scheme also revealed significant challenges.
Some government-appointed vendors began to hike prices for agricultural inputs, diminishing the value of the vouchers. Farmers were often forced to purchase items they did not need or could not derive full benefit from the vouchers due to inflated costs.
Other issues included double charging, and suppliers refusing to honour the vouchers. These problems highlighted the potential for middlemen to exploit their position.
It is challenging, however, to categorically state that middlemen do more harm than good.
While the examples of Desmanda Milk and the Pesi voucher scheme demonstrate instances where middlemen have caused significant issues, it is difficult to simply conclude that middlemen are more of a problem than a solution. However, there are more than enough examples to be concerned.
In the case of the Pesi vouchers, many beneficiaries did not receive the full value of their aid when they needed it most, and the dairy farmers’ situation illustrates how dependence on a single middleman can devastate livelihoods.
Striking a balance that works
Since working with middlemen can sometimes go well and sometimes not, it is important for farmers to reduce their dependency on these intermediaries where possible. Directly engaging with buyers can mitigate the risks associated with middlemen and provide farmers with more control over their operations and finances.
However, cutting out middlemen entirely is not always feasible, especially for small-scale farmers who may lack the resources or capacity to navigate complex market dynamics independently.
The key lies in finding a balanced approach that maximises the advantages while minimising the potential for exploitation and financial loss. By striking this balance, farmers can thrive, leveraging the strengths of middlemen while safeguarding against their pitfalls.
- Duncan Masiwa is the assistant editor at Food For Mzansi and the presenter of the television shows “Farming with nature” and “Boer saam met die natuur”. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of Food For Mzansi.
READ NEXT: SA fruit industry poised for stronger collaboration with government
Sign up for Mzansi Today: Your daily take on the news and happenings from the agriculture value chain.
