• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
Farming practices: Studies show that there are 2,500 billion tons of carbon in soil, compared with 800 billion tons in the atmosphere and 560 billion tons in plant and animal life. Healthier soil can store even more. Healthy plants with good roots capture further carbon from the atmosphere.

‘Build on goodwill between traditional authorities and agriculture’

25th December 2020
Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

2nd December 2023
Bureau Veritas has taken a bold step toward undertaking a solar and back-up project that allows it to sustain its business continuity for its Cape Town AgriFood Laboratory. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Bureau Veritas goes solar at Cape Town agrifood lab

2nd December 2023
Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

1st December 2023

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

1st December 2023
Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

1st December 2023
Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

1st December 2023
ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

1st December 2023
Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

1st December 2023
In pictures: Safeguarding indigenous plants for the future

In pictures: Safeguarding indigenous plants for the future

30th November 2023
Food for Mzansi gives voiceless farmers a much-needed voice

Food For Mzansi gives voiceless farmers a much-needed voice

30th November 2023
The Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity Group unveils the November 2023 Household Affordability Index, exposing surging expenses and stagnant wages affecting South African households. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Economic squeeze: Families struggle as costs soar

30th November 2023

Faces of Summer: Celebrate the rich history of Thokozani Wines

30th November 2023
Saturday, December 2, 2023
15 GLOBAL MEDIA AWARDS
Login
Food For Mzansi
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
Food For Mzansi
Home Food for Thought

‘Build on goodwill between traditional authorities and agriculture’

by Staff Reporter
25th December 2020
in Food for Thought
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Farming practices: Studies show that there are 2,500 billion tons of carbon in soil, compared with 800 billion tons in the atmosphere and 560 billion tons in plant and animal life. Healthier soil can store even more. Healthy plants with good roots capture further carbon from the atmosphere.

Ensuring that farmers maximise the true potential of the land includes the proper maintenance of their most precious asset: their soil. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

As the year draws to a close, it is worthwhile to reflect on one of the biggest highlights of 2020 in land reform. Geoff de Beer and Emile de Kock, transaction advisors with the Vumelana Advisory Fund, unpack some of the current models, challenges, gaps, and a possible way forward as we forge ahead. Vumelana is a non-profit organisation that helps beneficiaries of the land reform programme to make their land productive.

Government’s new plan to reallocate 700 000 hectares of underutilised state-owned land has been hailed as a quantum leap in the land reform programme. This move has also renewed interest in post-settlement solutions that can enable the success of land reform, driving effective utilisation to ensure productive use of land.

While this is a big milestone in the land reform programme, the initiative has been criticised for various reasons including threatening food security and spooking investors. Government has been criticised for its tardiness in speeding up the land redistribution programme and for not committing enough resources relative to the political rhetoric of redressing the wrongs of the past.

Current landscape 

Debunking the general perception of the failure of the land reform programme, De Kock stresses that the success of the programme should be measured by how quickly it is concluded, and not by the success or failure of the various enterprise undertakings including agriculture and tourism projects.

The Vumelana Advisory Fund helps communities in the land reform programme to develop their land. It also funds advisory services to structure commercially viable partnerships between communities and investors that create jobs, income and skills. Photo: Supplied

“How quickly can the land reform programme be implemented and concluded, and not how the associated projects perform, should be the measure we use to gauge the success of the programme.

“How the enterprises are performing on transferred land is a totally different question – it becomes an agricultural and an economics question, not a land reform question. So, it would be irresponsible to combine these two and pretend that land reform is some kind of economic sub-sector,” says De Kock.

He concedes that on both fronts – the speed of land reform implementation and the extent to which it has positively impacted the livelihoods of beneficiaries – the track record is disappointing.

De Kock attributes the slow pace of land reform programme to three factors: inadequate budget, resistance from interest groups and an absence of bureaucracy that is fit for purpose to implement and drive the process.

In 2016 the Vumelana Advisory Fund has awarded the Bela-Bela Communal Property Association in Limpopo with its Vumelana Governance Awards. Photo: Supplied

“There has never in the history of the new dispensation been a year where there was enough budget allocated to meet the land reform targets.

“It is not feasible to build a 5 000 kilometre stretch of tarred road with a budget allocation for three kilometres. Secondly, there is definitely a degree of resistance from interest groups within the political economy that does make it a little difficult.

“Thirdly, there has not been a reasonable amount of diligence applied in the bureaucracy of the mainstream land reform programme.

“What I mean by that is that land reform is a bureaucratic process. So you have targets, and you have processes and procedures, and if you combine budget with processes and procedures in order to achieve targets, then you have a bureaucracy at work,” he says.

De Beer adds that, “Often, beneficiaries of the land reform programme lack the requisite finance, skills and expertise to sustain the land and keep it productive. In most cases, the enterprises operating on properties – at the time of settling land claims are in a state of financial decline or have largely collapsed.

“This is no surprise, bearing in mind that even moderately sized enterprises are capital and skills intensive and operate in a highly competitive local, national and international environment.”

Current models in land reform 

De Beer explains that many communities have chosen to retain their ancestral land instead of taking a cash equivalent and have opted for a wide variety of arrangements to offset the lack of capital and expertise, with varying degrees of success.

Chief Barrington Mabuela (secretary of the Bela-Bela CPA), Andries Mabuela, Jarita Mabula (chairperson of the Bela-Bela CPA) and Peter Setou, the chief executive of the Vumelana Advisory Fund. Photo: Supplied
Chief Barrington Mabuela (secretary of the Bela-Bela CPA), Andries Mabuela, Jarita Mabula (chairperson of the Bela-Bela CPA) and Peter Setou, the chief executive of the Vumelana Advisory Fund. Photo: Supplied

Broadly speaking, these models have included (amongst others) collectives, service level agreements (or management contracts), various lease-based agreements, share-equity schemes, farm-worker-share-equity schemes and joint ventures,

De Beer notes that, While these models seem potentially commercially sound at face value, experience has shown that each one of these options has its own inherent pitfalls and solutions need to be designed and implemented on a case specific basis. The careful ‘up-front’ identification and allocation of these key aspects of risk/reward in all of these ‘partnerships’ is essential.”

He cautions that, “Failure to carefully and systematically design  these ‘partnerships’ to identify, engage  and agree on ways to mitigate or allocate such risks/responsibilities has led to the failure of many agricultural and tourism projects.”

Opportunity to implement the CPP model

De Beer says it is against this background that Vumelana developed the Community Private Partnership (CPP) model to provide much needed support to beneficiary communities to enable them to run commercially viable farms.

CPPs present one of the most viable options where beneficiary communities and the private sector enter into a win-win partnership for the management of the land. A critical aspect of the Vumelana support programme has been the use of experienced transaction advisors to assist the Claimant communities in the up-front design and legal contracting for the CPPs.

“There is goodwill between traditional authorities and the commercial agricultural sector in the former homelands, which presents a significant opportunity for meaningful CPP ventures.”

Vumelana has implemented the CPP model in a number of cases and it has proven to be a workable model. Case studies indicate that participation by the private sector via CPPs in the land reform programme has addressed the competency gaps for beneficiary communities by facilitating access to markets and finance, and has spurred investment in production and employment and led to skills transfer.

Support for CPI administration should be an integral part of supporting beneficiary communities. Communities are becoming owners of large capital investments, but they generally do not have the necessary governance and management structures and capabilities.

As a result, they require professional services. Institutionalising community support should become an integral part of the post-land claims process to manage community expectations and aspirations,” comments De Beer.

De Kock says the planned allocation of 700 000 hectares presents a great opportunity to implement the CPP model in some of the instances where communities apply for land. He says that experience has shown that the productive potential of the land, coupled with the cohesiveness of the community, are the two important factors that can attract potential investors.

“All that land tends to be already in use by smallholder livestock and fresh produce farmers, and therefore it is logical and beneficial that those people and families who had been arriving on the land for the past five decades or more should have the opportunity to formalise the tenure over that land through the new policy,” says De Kock.

“There is a great amount of goodwill between traditional authorities and the commercial agricultural sector in the former homelands, which presents a significant opportunity for meaningful CPP ventures to be developed on those former commercial estates in state land areas.

“It would be necessary to develop transparent protocols for such partnerships to be concluded in a manner that is compliant with state policy. There are also large pieces of land with limited productive potential in the former homeland areas, including grazing land and smallholder cultivation plots,” concludes De Kock.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • WhatsApp
  • Email
Tags: 700 000 hectarescommunity private partnershipCPPEmile de KockGeoff de BeerLand reformunderutilised state-owned landVumelana Advisory Fund
Previous Post

A farmer’s (weighty!) Christmas dilemma

Next Post

Meet the Gugs queen who started 8 veggie gardens

Staff Reporter

Staff Reporter

Researched and written by our team of writers and editors.

Related Posts

CPAs need good governance for private-sector land reform support

CPAs need good governance for private-sector land reform support

by Peter Setou
27th November 2023
0

Good governance within Communal Property Associations is vital since the success of land reform hinges on it, writes Peter Setou,...

ICYMI: Khomani San celebrates successful NC land claim

ICYMI: Khomani San celebrates successful NC land claim

by Staff Reporter
2nd November 2023
0

Land reform remains a headache for the South African government, however, for the Khomani San community in the Kgalagadi Transfrontier...

ICYMI: Corruption and lack of post-settlement support sink CPAs

ICYMI: Corruption and lack of post-settlement support sink CPAs

by Staff Reporter
12th October 2023
0

Infighting, corruption, and lack of support and skills are just some of the issues that cause CPAs to fail. This...

EC family waits for promised rights to ancestral farmland

EC family waits for promised rights to ancestral farmland

by Lucas Nowicki
7th October 2023
0

After years of empty promises and failed attempts to get their lease finalised, the Matya family in the Eastern Cape...

Next Post
Nomonde Kweza is an award-winning farmer and the owner of, among others, the Ulimo Lwethu food garden in Gugulethu, Cape Town. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Meet the Gugs queen who started 8 veggie gardens

News

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

by Team Food For Mzansi
1st December 2023
0

Farmers share their gratitude towards Food For Mzansi for paving the way forward as they build their farming enterprises. From...

Read more
Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

1st December 2023
Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

1st December 2023
ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

ChickenFacts calls for new Poultry Master Plan amid trade turmoil

1st December 2023
Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

Food inflation fury grips Mzansi: BFAP sounds alarm

1st December 2023

Rural resilience: Women in farming project triumphs

Legal eagle turned #SoilSista Booi empowers as she goes along

10 out of 10: Farmers share what Food For Mzansi means to them

CPAs need good governance for private-sector land reform support

Agro-processing offers endless opportunities, tap into them now!

Sorghum remains a great choice amid climate challenge

RSS From FoodForAfrika.com

  • $2 Million investment in fertiliser financing for Kenyan smallholders
  • AfDB empowers Tanzanian horticulture with $2.5m boost
  • Malagasy scientist wins $150k grant

THE NEW FACE OF SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE

With 15 global awards in the first four years of its existence, Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication. It is a movement, unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture. We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society.

Top tips to prevent fire burns this festive season

Bureau Veritas goes solar at Cape Town agrifood lab

Podcast: How to access fresh produce markets in SA

Food For Mzansi serves as ideal launching pad for farmers

Let this saucy oxtail recipe take you back down memory lane

Arendse puts her eggs in many baskets while aiming for the skies

  • Our Story
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright

Contact us
Office: +27 21 879 1824
News: info@foodformzansi.co.za
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
Login

Copyright © 2021 Food for Mzansi

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.