• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • News
  • Lifestyle
Agricultural economist Malapane Thamaga believes if farmers operate as a collective it enables them to negotiate for good prices rather that competing amongst themselves, leading to buyers dictating their prices. Photo: Supplied

Acting collectively, smallholders pool their power

24th Mar 2021
Kgapane Phillip is a grower of note, dedicated to providing his environment with a variety of fresh produce grown with pride. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

How this Limpopo vegetable farmer milked the market

4th Jul 2022
South Africa's organic fruit industry needs some focused attention if it is to participate in the global market. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

What’s holding Mzansi’s organic fruit producers back?

4th Jul 2022
This week's Gather To Grow interactive session on Twitter has farmers and experts talking cabbage farming. Photo: Food For Mzansi

This week’s agriculture events: 04 July to 08 July 2022

4th Jul 2022
Farmworker rights came under the spotlight once again. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Farmworker rights: Committee calls for clampdown

4th Jul 2022
This week on the Farmer’s Inside Track Weekend Edition, we take a closer look at the Master Plan for the Commercial Forestry Sector in South Africa. We’re joined by the executive director of Forestry South Africa, Michael Peter paints an intriguing picture.Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

SA forestry: Dynamite on a small patch of land

3rd Jul 2022
The war on plant-based foods has erupted in South Africa. Photo: LikeMeat/Unsplash

War on veggie meat names ‘to protect consumers’

2nd Jul 2022
What to look for when formulating dairy cow rations

What to look for when formulating dairy cow rations

1st Jul 2022
Leave your comfort zone and make money, says foodie

Leave your comfort zone and start hustling, says foodie

1st Jul 2022
Recipe: Make Makile’s crispy chicken wings

Recipe: Make Makile’s crispy chicken wings

1st Jul 2022
Experts have warned farmers to prepare for another steep fuel price increase this month. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Caught in a price spiral: Farmers brace for major losses

1st Jul 2022
Parts of the Western Cape, such as the Central Karoo, are still experiencing drought. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Drought-burdened farmers receive R48m. in fodder

1st Jul 2022
Through his company, Iboyana agri farming, Mhlengi Ngcobo is changing the lives of youth and women in his community. Photo:Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Self-taught farmer doing his bit for the greater good

30th Jun 2022
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
11 GLOBAL MEDIA AWARDS
Mon, Jul 4, 2022
Food For Mzansi
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
    • All
    • AgriCareers
    • Entrepreneurs
    • Farmers
    • Groundbreakers
    • Innovators
    • Inspiration
    • It Takes a Village
    • Mentors
    • Movers and Shakers
    • Partnerships
    Kgapane Phillip is a grower of note, dedicated to providing his environment with a variety of fresh produce grown with pride. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    How this Limpopo vegetable farmer milked the market

    Through his company, Iboyana agri farming, Mhlengi Ngcobo is changing the lives of youth and women in his community. Photo:Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Self-taught farmer doing his bit for the greater good

    Reggie Kambule from Villiers in the Free State runs a 185 hectare farm where he breeds livestock and cultivates maize. Photo:Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Engineer-turned farmer takes pride in good results

    Agripreneur 101: Sweet success for jam producer

    Agripreneur 101: Sweet success for jam producer

    Real Housewife turns passion for wine into a business

    Real Housewife turns passion for wine into a business

    David Mthombeni is building an agriculture empire for his family.Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Farmer gets his hands dirty while building family empire

    Gauteng farmers give youth a leg-up in agriculture

    Women in farming give youth a leg up in agriculture

    Watch out, these young farmers are on fire!

    Watch out, these young farmers are on fire!

    Unati Speirs has vast experience in agri-business strategy and business funding and was recently appointed as a new board director for Hortgro. Photos: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

    Youngest Hortgro hotshot takes transformation to heart

  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought
No Result
View All Result
Food For Mzansi

Acting collectively, smallholders pool their power

by Malapane Thamaga
24th Mar 2021
in Farmer's Inside Track, Food for Thought
Reading Time: 9 mins read
A A
Agricultural economist Malapane Thamaga believes if farmers operate as a collective it enables them to negotiate for good prices rather that competing amongst themselves, leading to buyers dictating their prices. Photo: Supplied

Agricultural economist Malapane Thamaga believes if farmers operate as a collective it enables them to negotiate for good prices rather that competing amongst themselves, leading to buyers dictating their prices. Photo: Supplied

Malapane Thamaga holds a BSc Agricultural Economics (Honours) from Stellenbosch University. He is the former national manager of AFASA, and has also worked as an agricultural economist for the National Emergent Redmeat Producers Organisation (NERPO). Thamaga is deeply passionate about agricultural policy, rural development, agricultural markets, and agricultural finance. As a consultant, these days he works with up-and-coming farmers, cooperatives and commodities focusing on agricultural development programmes and market linkages.

Agricultural economist Malapane Thamaga believes South Africa’s farmers can benefit from the power of collective action through an agricultural clustering model. In this thought provoking article he encourages new farmers to take advantage of economies of scale through agricultural clustering. He shares a number of lessons from the communal wool farmers and smallholder flower producers in Mzansi. 


Farmers are better-off working together as a collective and complementing each other rather than competing among themselves. The Sepedi saying that “Tau tsa hloka seboka dishitwa ke nare e hlotsa” (loosely translated as lions hunting independently fail to even prey on a limping buffalo) comes to mind.

This is the case in business and even more relevant for emerging farmers. The contrasting approach is by taking advantage of economies of scale through agricultural clustering.

With Rift Valley Fever upon us, farmers are encouraged to vaccinate their livestock against this deadly disease. This virus is known for causing outbreaks of abortions and deaths of livestock (predominantly sheep, goats and cattle). Operating independently would make it expensive for emerging farmers to embark on this operation.

However, as a collective, farmers may take advantage of economies of scale, cluster together and work on a vaccination programme that would make it easier even for those owning few livestock to vaccinate their stocks. This idea may even work for collectively purchasing feed directly from the manufacturer at a lesser price. This is made possible by the magic in the form of economies of scale.

ADVERTISEMENT

ALSO READ: Grant to transform FS communal woolgrowers

Economics of scale 

The idea of economies of scale is among the first concepts you learn in your first-year agricultural economics, that is that there is power in numbers. Strictly speaking, economists define economies of scale as the cost advantages that enterprises obtain due to their scale of operation resulting in decreasing average cost of production per unit.

This concept is best described through the possibility of purchasing inputs at a lower per-unit cost when they are purchased in large quantities. Unfortunately, the majority of emerging farmers operate in small scale and are unable to purchase products in large quantities as individuals.

However, there exist an opportunity to reduce costs per unit when they explore the possibility of working together through what I would rather refer to as cluster farming or agricultural clustering. This is similar to the concept of cooperatives.

Unfortunately, the term cooperative is tainted and has negative connotations in the South African context as the majority of these entities tend to be dysfunctional mainly due to the free rider problem and opportunistic behaviour. This means some members work harder than others while some lazy members only appear during harvest or only when the entity has just received some funding.

ALSO READ: Women’s farming cooperative opens doors for others

Understanding agricultural clusters 

Perhaps the problem lies in how cooperatives are formulated in South Africa. In most cases, they are established to tick the right boxes, as this is a preferred entity for getting funded by government. It is out of opportunistic behaviour that people would quickly identify five people from the community, irrespective of their interest in farming, and use their names to establish a cooperative. The consequences of this are dire. As a result, there is no business minded farmer who is interested to listen when you speak of cooperatives. Hence, my preference for agricultural clustering.

The good thing is that the communal wool farmers, especially in the former Transkei and Ciskei region of the Eastern Cape, have been practicing the model of agricultural clustering for years with support from the National Wool Growers Association (NWGA). NWGA is a commodity group whose responsibility is mainly to promote the wool industry in South Africa through information sharing, investment in research and development and being the voice of the wool farmers in policy engagements. Among other roles that NWGA play include investing in shearing sheds, training in wool sorting, shearing and other farming practices for communal farmers.

Agricultural clusters refer to “a concentration of producers, agribusinesses and institutions that are engaged in the same agricultural or agro-industrial subsector, and interconnect and build value networks when addressing common challenges and pursuing common opportunities”. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Operating as a collective also enables farmers to negotiate for a good prices rather than competing among themselves and leading to buyers dictating their prices.

The idea of agricultural clusters is derived from the concept of economic clusters as found in other industries. While agricultural clusters are concerned with addressing farmers’ common goals in agriculture, economic clusters on the other hand refers to “a geographically bounded group of similar, interconnected and often complementary firms that share infrastructures and a common institutional environment”. The classic examples of economic clusters include Silicon Valley, home to many start-up and global technology companies, in the United States.

Agricultural clustering may take two forms, namely an area- or commodity-based approach. In the area-based approach, farmers come together based on the proximity of farms and trading posts, while in the commodity-based approach, farmers plant the same type of produce and combine their produce to achieve a higher volume.

Whatever form of agricultural cluster is followed, the cluster development model enables a group of farmers to collaborate on purchases for their input requirements, shared machinery services and marketing agricultural produce together. 

These farmers may then acquire support necessary to produce a single crop or variety to similar standards on each of their own farms. The aggregate output of the farmers is then combined and sold to a client. Operating as a collective also enables farmers to negotiate for a good prices rather than competing among themselves and leading to buyers dictating their prices.

Unfortunately, individual emerging farmers are unlikely to produce the needed agricultural volumes required by the market and this may leave them opting to sell their produce through the not so reliable informal market. 

ALSO READ: Data: The invisible gap holding back smallholders

Accessing markets 

Typically, agricultural clusters operate in the form of a business trust owned by farmers or a not-for-profit company. I recommend the latter as it is less complex and easy to manage. In most cases they partner with an already established agribusiness with Global Gap certification and access to a market partner with nearby farms to assist them with technical expertise. This is to ensure quality of production and that generally accepted agricultural practices are followed. While an existing entity operates in their own name, they engage the clustered farmers through the NPC which also plays an aggregator role for marketing purposes and inputs distribution. 

Another such good example of agricultural clustering is the Timbali platform, a Mpumalanga Province based technology incubator enterprise established in 2003 to support start-up floriculture entrepreneurs in overcoming their challenges. Timbali started with only 10 farmers and now support about 185 farmers.

Communal flower farmers

The incubator platform supports growers with technical expertise, financial administration skills and access to markets. Through their marketing arm, AmaBlom, these clustered smallholder florist farmers markets over 5,5 million flowers annually, sold mainly in the South African market. To this end, they have created 700 jobs with a combined annual turnover of R11.6 million.

Note that unlike in the commonly practiced cooperatives, here farmers continue to operate individually on their own farms but are brought together through a common goal of achieving economies of scale.

It is however important that the clustered farmers are strict and do not compromise on quality of the produce.

This can be achieved by not allowing mediocre products to contaminate products of higher grade.

The communal wool farmers, on the other hand, cluster themselves under what are commonly referred to as wool growers’ associations. Communal farmers in these areas own from as little as five sheep per household to as many as 200 sheep per household. Unfortunately, wool is only sold through bales weighing between 100 kg and 190 kg per bale. 

One bale is typically made by 60 skirted fleeces, i.e. about 60 sheep. However, for farmers to add value to their wool, it must be sorted into different classes for uniformity purposes so that each bale is made up of wool of similar length, fineness, strength and are from sheep of the same breed. In this way farmers increase their chances of fetching higher prices at wool auctions undertaken under the auspices of the Cape Wools in Port Elizabeth. 

Accordingly, farmers enjoy shared access to infrastructure such as the shearing shed, bale pressers and services essential for wool marketing such as shearers, classers and transport to take wool to Port Elizabeth. Unfortunately, communal farmers have not explored extensively the idea of buying inputs, such as medication and feed, as a collective. If this opportunity is explored further, communal sheep farmers would likely increase the quality of their wool and meat which will lead to increased profitability. This strategy may go a long way in fighting disease outbreaks such as Rift Valley Fever.

ALSO READ: Secret to better farmer incomes lies in soil health

Tags: agricultural clustersEconomics of scaleNational Wool Growers’ AssociationRift Valley Fever
Previous Post

RSA Group bags top accreditation at Tshwane market

Next Post

SIYABONGA: Register now for free virtual farmers’ day

Malapane Thamaga

Malapane Thamaga

Malapane Thamaga holds Hons BSc Agricultural Economics from the University of Stellenbosch. He is the former National Manager of the African Farmers Association of South Africa (AFASA), has also worked as an Agricultural Economist at the National Emergent Redmeat Producers Organisation (NERPO). His introduction to the agricultural sector was through BKB Ltd Graduate Programme. His general interests in the agricultural sector include agricultural policy, rural development, agricultural markets, and agricultural finance. He’s currently doing consultation work with emerging farmers, cooperatives and commodities focusing on agricultural development programmes and market linkages.

Related Posts

Despite the prevailing wool market uncertainty, Mzansi's wool industry is looking forward to a positive 2022. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

Market uncertainty not dimming wool farmers’ spirits

by Zolani Sinxo
20th Jan 2022
0

Mzansi's wool farmers are cautiously optimistic about the world returning to its pre-Covid buzz. About 95% of our wool clip...

Podcast: Farmer's Inside Track

Podcast: Be on the lookout for Rift Valley fever

by Nicole Ludolph
1st Sep 2021
0

It has a mortality rate of up to 100% in young animals. In adults, it can cause abortion storms. Preventative...

Impoundment controversyurged to vaccinate their cattle, sheep and goats against Rift Valley fever. Photo: Supplied/WHO/TDR/Simon Lim

Vaccinate now to guard animals against Rift Valley fever

by Staff Reporter
31st Aug 2021
0

Officially, the next Rift Valley fever outbreak is only expected in 2030, but a leading Afrivet veterinarian believes the latest...

Wool industry finding its feet amid Covid-19 hurdles

by Noluthando Ngcakani
15th Mar 2021
0

Wool prices sprung to life gaining a 1% increase in auction sales of bales on local and international markets. The...

Next Post
All roads lead to Wellington in the Western Cape for SIYABONGA Day on Wednesday, 31 March. On the speaker line-up is Breyton Milford from Agri-Expo, Wendy Petersen from the SA Wine Industry Transformation Unit and Denise Stubbs from Thokozani Wines. Photos: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

SIYABONGA: Register now for free virtual farmers' day

Farmworker rights came under the spotlight once again. Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi
News

Farmworker rights: Committee calls for clampdown

by Staff Reporter
4th Jul 2022
0

In case you missed it: A joint parliamentary oversight committee on labour and agriculture visited farms in North West and...

Read more
This week on the Farmer’s Inside Track Weekend Edition, we take a closer look at the Master Plan for the Commercial Forestry Sector in South Africa. We’re joined by the executive director of Forestry South Africa, Michael Peter paints an intriguing picture.Photo: Supplied/Food For Mzansi

SA forestry: Dynamite on a small patch of land

3rd Jul 2022
The war on plant-based foods has erupted in South Africa. Photo: LikeMeat/Unsplash

War on veggie meat names ‘to protect consumers’

2nd Jul 2022
What to look for when formulating dairy cow rations

What to look for when formulating dairy cow rations

1st Jul 2022
Leave your comfort zone and make money, says foodie

Leave your comfort zone and start hustling, says foodie

1st Jul 2022

How this Limpopo vegetable farmer milked the market

Beef up your understanding of SA’s red meat industry

Engineer-turned farmer takes pride in good results

Technology not a priority for Africa’s smallholder farmers

Recipe: Make Makile’s crispy chicken wings

Leave your comfort zone and start hustling, says foodie

THE NEW FACE OF SOUTH AFRICAN AGRICULTURE

With 11 global awards in the first three years of its existence, Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication. It is a movement, unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture. We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society.

How this Limpopo vegetable farmer milked the market

What’s holding Mzansi’s organic fruit producers back?

This week’s agriculture events: 04 July to 08 July 2022

Farmworker rights: Committee calls for clampdown

SA forestry: Dynamite on a small patch of land

War on veggie meat names ‘to protect consumers’

  • Our Story
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright

Contact us
Office: +27 21 879 1824
WhatsApp line: +27 81 889 9032
Marketing: +27 71 147 0388
News: info@foodformzansi.co.za
Advertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Changemakers
  • Lifestyle
  • Farmer’s Inside Track
  • Food for Thought

Copyright © 2021 Food for Mzansi

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Go to mobile version